Toleration and pluralism are two principles that, when embraced together, serve as the blueprint of a free and thriving society. Toleration begins with a simple but profound idea: so long as a person is not harming others in a substantive way, their speech, behavior, and beliefs should be legally protected and socially accepted. It establishes a framework of peaceful coexistence—one that allows people to disagree without resorting to coercion. Pluralism builds upon toleration, going further to argue not only that individuals with different worldviews, faiths, and practices can live together peacefully, but also that society as a whole benefits from their differences.
Together, these principles reflect the liberal understanding of human society as inherently diverse, dynamic, and decentralized. They reject authoritarian impulses to impose conformity, whether through law or cultural pressure, in favor of voluntary association, experimentation, and exchange. The result is a society that is more resilient, innovative, and humane—precisely the kind of society that liberalism seeks to create and preserve.
Toleration and Pluralism
Artwork commissioned by the Institute for Humane Studies
Toleration: Protecting Liberty in Difference
Toleration is the starting point of a free society. It recognizes that individuals have the right to make choices about their beliefs, identities, and ways of life without interference, so long as they do not infringe on the rights of others. This principle traces back to the Enlightenment, when thinkers like John Locke argued for religious toleration not as a concession, but as a moral imperative. Persecuting someone for their beliefs, Locke argued, does nothing to change their mind and only corrupts the legitimacy of the state.
Applied broadly, toleration means that people should be free to live according to their values, even when others find those values objectionable. Whether it’s a family practicing a minority religion, an artist creating provocative work, or an activist promoting unpopular ideas, a liberal society defends their freedom to do so. Legal protections for freedom of speech, religion, and association codify this commitment, ensuring that disagreements remain peaceful rather than coercive.
A society committed to toleration avoids the impulse to marginalize or ostracize those who deviate from majority opinions. It recognizes that disagreement is not a threat but a feature of a healthy democracy.
But toleration is more than a legal framework; it’s also a cultural norm. A society committed to toleration avoids the impulse to marginalize or ostracize those who deviate from majority opinions. It recognizes that disagreement is not a threat but a feature of a healthy democracy. This mindset allows people to learn from one another, correct errors, and refine their own views.
However, toleration does not mean endorsement. It does not require anyone to agree with or approve of the choices others make. Instead, it acknowledges that disagreement can coexist with mutual respect—and that such respect is essential for a society grounded in liberty.
Pluralism: Strength Through Diversity
If toleration is the foundation, then pluralism is the structure built on top of it. Pluralism doesn’t merely accept diversity; it actively values it. It recognizes that different perspectives, traditions, and lifestyles contribute to human flourishing—not in spite of their differences, but because of them.
Religious pluralism, for instance, demonstrates how communities with fundamentally different worldviews can live together peacefully while enriching each other’s lives. The American experiment, built in part on religious freedom, has shown that a society does not need to be homogenous to be stable or successful. Instead, it can draw strength from its diversity, creating an environment where people of all faiths—or none at all—coexist and collaborate.
This principle extends beyond religion. In a pluralistic society, cultural, ideological, and economic diversity fuels innovation and adaptability. Different experiences and viewpoints generate new ideas, challenge stagnant assumptions, and create opportunities for cooperation. Historically, pluralistic societies have been more dynamic and better equipped to handle social and technological change.
By welcoming competing ideas and voices, pluralism counteracts the centralizing tendencies of authoritarianism and populism, keeping power distributed and accountable.
Pluralism also plays a key role in democracy. It ensures that political debates reflect the complexity of society, rather than flattening it into simplistic stereotypes. By welcoming competing ideas and voices, pluralism counteracts the centralizing tendencies of authoritarianism and populism, keeping power distributed and accountable.
Yet pluralism is not without tension. It requires continuous negotiation and compromise, especially in a world where deeply held values often conflict. The strength of a pluralistic society lies in its ability to manage these tensions without resorting to coercion. It thrives when individuals approach differences not with hostility, but with curiosity and humility—qualities that toleration helps to instill.
The Liberal Case for Living Together in Freedom
Toleration and pluralism are not merely abstract ideals; they are practical principles that sustain free societies. Toleration protects individuals from coercion, allowing them to pursue their own beliefs and values without fear. Pluralism transforms this freedom into collective strength, turning differences into sources of growth and resilience. Together, they provide the blueprint for a society where liberty, diversity, and cooperation can thrive.
But these principles are not self-sustaining. They require ongoing defense against the forces of intolerance and authoritarianism, whether they arise from the left, the right, or the extremes of populism. Illiberal movements that seek to enforce conformity—whether through censorship, cultural homogenization, or state power—pose a direct threat to the pluralistic order that makes democracy possible.
Liberals must be unapologetic in making the case for toleration and pluralism, especially in an era of rising polarization.
Liberals must be unapologetic in making the case for toleration and pluralism, especially in an era of rising polarization. This means standing against both legal restrictions on speech and cultural pressures to silence dissent. It means promoting policies that expand freedom of association, religious liberty, and economic opportunity. And it means resisting the temptation to retreat into tribalism—instead reaffirming the shared commitment to live together in freedom.
Ultimately, toleration and pluralism are more than principles—they are practices. They shape how we engage with one another, how we resolve conflicts, and how we define ourselves as a people. In defending these practices, we defend not only liberalism but also the very idea of a society built on freedom and mutual respect. It is this vision that offers the surest path to progress, prosperity, and peace.
By supporting IHS, you invest in scholars at a formative stage in their careers. Not only with crucial financial support, but with inspiration and connections to other like-minded and driven intellectual collaborators that they can’t find from any other funder.
